A Lesson in Maintenance Approach

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
3,585
Location
USA
Vessel Name
Catalina Jack
Vessel Make
Defever 44
Over many years reading topics here, I have observed a profound tendency for assuming and pursuing the worst of causes of problems rather than starting with the simple, the basics. We dive, myself included at times, deep into the complicated and expensive. Well, I succumbed to this tendency myself just two days ago. My reason for relating this story is to suggest to readers to please, start with the basics. Do not assume the worst.

My mechanical problem was with a vehicle, not on a boat but it doesn't matter in principle. My wife and I were 60 miles away from Everett, WA on a road trip from Maryland to visit our son (US Navy lifer). Just after summiting Steven's Pass on US 2, our Chevy Tahoe died. The day before it had become hard to start. We had to get it towed (AAA) 60 miles to a Chevy dealer. My guess the problem was oxygen sensors as the symptoms before it quit completely were consistent with failed sensors.

Well, today I got a call today from the dealer with good news. A $12 repair, a broken clamp which separated the air cleaner and Mass Air Flow Sensor from the engine intake. The engine computer was getting bad info from the MAF sensor and the engine died. Moral of the story? Start simple. Check the obvious, the apparent. I never even opened the hood. What abject stupidy! My only comfort is that, with a broken clamp, I may not have been able to effect a repair but I am probably kidding myself. I may have been able to rig something to get me going.

Anyway, start with the simple and work deeper later.
 
Over many years reading topics here, I have observed a profound tendency for assuming and pursuing the worst of causes of problems rather than starting with the simple, the basics. We dive, myself included at times, deep into the complicated and expensive. Well, I succumbed to this tendency myself just two days ago. My reason for relating this story is to suggest to readers to please, start with the basics. Do not assume the worst.

My mechanical problem was with a vehicle, not on a boat but it doesn't matter in principle. My wife and I were 60 miles away from Everett, WA on a road trip from Maryland to visit our son (US Navy lifer). Just after summiting Steven's Pass on US 2, our Chevy Tahoe died. The day before it had become hard to start. We had to get it towed (AAA) 60 miles to a Chevy dealer. My guess the problem was oxygen sensors as the symptoms before it quit completely were consistent with failed sensors.

Well, today I got a call today from the dealer with good news. A $12 repair, a broken clamp which separated the air cleaner and Mass Air Flow Sensor from the engine intake. The engine computer was getting bad info from the MAF sensor and the engine died. Moral of the story? Start simple. Check the obvious, the apparent. I never even opened the hood. What abject stupidy! My only comfort is that, with a broken clamp, I may not have been able to effect a repair but I am probably kidding myself. I may have been able to rig something to get me going.

Anyway, start with the simple and work deeper later.
Totally agree, something not working? Start to check if it is plugged. Sounds stupid but this is RCA step 1.

L
 
Agree. Windshield washer stopped working. Replaced the pump. no joy. Replaced the level sensor. Nothing. replaced the coolant level sensor. Still dead. Took it to a mechanic for replacement of expensive electronic module.

He tightened a ground screw. (The screw was right next to my hand when I replaced the pump and sensor and to make it worse, I keep a voltmeter in the trunk)
 
Well, today I got a call today from the dealer with good news. A $12 repair,


You're lucky. If I take my diesel pu to the dealer, sensors start at $300. So I bought the diagnostic software and got the money back on the first failure. If I was younger, I'd put a mechanical Detroit in the truck.
 
One of my first Porsche instructors taught the "touchy-feely" method. Physically touch and wiggle every connector. It works. But sometimes you still have to replace something expensive.
 
Hooray for the Chevy shop that did not see the need to do exploratory surgery!!!
 
You're lucky. If I take my diesel pu to the dealer, sensors start at $300. So I bought the diagnostic software and got the money back on the first failure. If I was younger, I'd put a mechanical Detroit in the truck.


That's the way to do it. People love to complain that modern stuff is hard to diagnose, but that's only true if you don't have the right info. If you have the documentation and the software, you can usually just ask it what hurts.
 
Flying for an airline when things broke we picked up a mic and called it in to maintenance. They would then send one or two people out to start the fixing process.

One time someone called something in and the MX controller asked if the "oh enn oh eff eff" switch was in the "oh enn" position. A long and meaningful silence followed.......
 
It is interesting that when something breaks we often start with the most complicated and obscure reason first and then work backwards to the most simple.
 
It is interesting that when something breaks we often start with the most complicated and obscure reason first and then work backwards to the most simple.

The definition of a pessimist.
 
Back
Top Bottom