I have owned a couple of later Mainships: a single engine 34T and a single engine Pilot 34. The factory props were spot on, letting the Yanmar 370 rev to 3,400 rpm with a clean bottom. So my experience and that of others is that Mainship props its boats reasonably.
In one recent case the PO had put on a higher pitch prop with the mistaken objective of saving fuel at low rpms. So check for that. You seem to have covered the other issues, throttle not opening completely and the tach being off, but in my experience the tach was pretty close. Also check for the prop or bottom being dirty. What rpms do you get at wot in neutral. Should hit about 3,500 rpm.
David