She says "size doesn't matter"

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
See posts with no answers
Update: First of all thanks everyone for all the comments. Free information is like beer, it should never be turned down (you just don't have to drink it all). The boat looked good and was well taken care of by the second owner. The aft deck had been rebuilt along with other areas of the deck, new plumbing and wiring, new gel coat on the hull and some new interior in 05. The Isuzu engine (125 hp), was massive and in good shape, clean and in order. With 1000 hrs it looked more old than used. The biggest problem was the interior height. It was less than 6', I'm 5-11" and I kept skinning the top of my head, that was in the main cabin and that's not going to fly. I don't have that kind of hair to waste! It's a great boat for a short family.

Any how the search continues.
 
otis maximus said:
Update: First of all thanks everyone for all the comments. Free information is like beer, it should never be turned down (you just don't have to drink it all). The boat looked good and was well taken care of by the second owner. The aft deck had been rebuilt along with other areas of the deck, new plumbing and wiring, new gel coat on the hull and some new interior in 05. The Isuzu engine (125 hp), was massive and in good shape, clean and in order. With 1000 hrs it looked more old than used. The biggest problem was the interior height. It was less than 6', I'm 5-11" and I kept skinning the top of my head, that was in the main cabin and that's not going to fly. I don't have that kind of hair to waste! It's a great boat for a short family.

Any how the search continues.
Click to expand...

Wifey B: You certainly showed the reason to get on the boat and check it out thoroughly. Interior height is always a consideration for us and we don't trust anyone's numbers. I think sometimes those that are so close like the 6' vs your 5'11" are the worst as you hit based on how you walk and what you're doing so you think you clear until you bang your head. :eek:
 
Size and guesstimates

We are new to trawlers, having just bought our first, a Cheoy Lee 40 LRC, but we went through the same "how big does it have to be, and how small can it be" dance in narrowing our search.
We had camped in everything from an oilcloth and wool blankets to a 12 x 20 tent with king bed, dressing room, and dining room, and realized that at this stage of our lives. we like our comfort.

To us this meant a walk around queen bed, and space for at least two comfortable chairs to read in, and 6'4" headroom.
Other requirements were side decks wide enough to handle mooring lines safely, good engines, solid construction, good i terior spaces, and well cared for.
To get the walk around queen in a smaller boat meant an aft cabin, which put our minimum size around 40'.
We want to do the Loop, so draft under 5' was necessary. ee wanted a decent galley and a shower I could fit in.
Headroom was the larger problem, but internet search narrowed it down to 7 possible makes and models, then we went looking at boats in person.
Best of luck on your search.
 
First post here and yes this thread went to the dark side for a while. We are now 6 years back from 3 year, 10,000 NM sabbatical sailing the east coast of the US and the Caribbean on a 41ft catamaran. Starting to think about my next foray which I think will be on a trawler and west coast based.

I think there is a magic length of boat where you can check all the boxes that are important for long(er) term cruising. In the sailing world I think this would be a 36ft monohull and sense the same for a trawler. Too many get caught up with saving for the perfect boat only to never achieve their objective because of $$ (and can never get their head around what the right boat is). Get a boat and go.
After some time you will find out what is important to you and you can always upgrade/downgrade based on what you learn. Big boats are considerably more work to look after and this increases exponentially with length. At 41ft, a buff and wax of our topsides was a 2 day back breaking job that we did every 4-5 months (half done standing/crouching in the tender ... but always in a spectacular anchorage). We never had the funds to have this work done for us (nor did we want to). I could write a book on adventures in getting propane. Sadly the person who checks in and tasks the marina with this is missing all the best and most memorable parts of cruising (ya mon, I dink dere is some propane on da udderside of the island mon (yeah right!)). Generally speaking I think the people cruising on limited budgets and smaller platforms have richer experiences because it not so much about the destination its about the people you meet and often financial status can get in the way of this. But I diverge so will stop here.
 
Bigbeam said:
First post here and yes this thread went to the dark side for a while. We are now 6 years back from 3 year, 10,000 NM sabbatical sailing the east coast of the US and the Caribbean on a 41ft catamaran. Starting to think about my next foray which I think will be on a trawler and west coast based.

I think there is a magic length of boat where you can check all the boxes that are important for long(er) term cruising. In the sailing world I think this would be a 36ft monohull and sense the same for a trawler. Too many get caught up with saving for the perfect boat only to never achieve their objective because of $$ (and can never get their head around what the right boat is). Get a boat and go.
After some time you will find out what is important to you and you can always upgrade/downgrade based on what you learn. Big boats are considerably more work to look after and this increases exponentially with length. At 41ft, a buff and wax of our topsides was a 2 day back breaking job that we did every 4-5 months (half done standing/crouching in the tender ... but always in a spectacular anchorage). We never had the funds to have this work done for us (nor did we want to). I could write a book on adventures in getting propane. Sadly the person who checks in and tasks the marina with this is missing all the best and most memorable parts of cruising (ya mon, I dink dere is some propane on da udderside of the island mon (yeah right!)). Generally speaking I think the people cruising on limited budgets and smaller platforms have richer experiences because it not so much about the destination its about the people you meet and often financial status can get in the way of this. But I diverge so will stop here.
Click to expand...

Welcome to the forum!

Interesting first time post. A few misconceptions based on cruising sailboats. A more frugal vessel doesn't make the experience better (common sailor misconception). If it's not about where you're going and what you're seeing, why leave home waters? Ideal size is about where you want to go, what you want to do (bicycle, kayak, explore, etc), and how many people will be on the boat, both full time and guests.

Ted
 
Guest are unskilled laborer.
 
Perhaps this is the time to ask, when one says 41 feet, are we talking OAL plus the swim platform?
Seems the boat builders are NOW counting the swim platform in overall length.
I bought a AT34 which is now called a 36 because the builder started adding in the swim platform. I asked him why to which his response was basically, everyone else is doing it. SHRUG
 
O C Diver said:
Welcome to the forum!

Interesting first time post. A few misconceptions based on cruising sailboats. A more frugal vessel doesn't make the experience better (common sailor misconception). If it's not about where you're going and what you're seeing, why leave home waters? Ideal size is about where you want to go, what you want to do (bicycle, kayak, explore, etc), and how many people will be on the boat, both full time and guests.

Ted
Click to expand...

I agree its not about the frugal vessel making the experience better.

I think you missed the point Bigbeam was making. It is often the frugal adventure which is more interesting than the all inclusive holiday in the gated community.
 
AusCan said:
I agree its not about the frugal vessel making the experience better.

I think you missed the point Bigbeam was making. It is often the frugal adventure which is more interesting than the all inclusive holiday in the gated community.
Click to expand...

You're obviously reading a lot between the lines somewhere as he said nothing of that nature.

Here are his exact words after espousing the joy of washing and waxing vs. having a marina do it.

Bigbeam said:
Generally speaking I think the people cruising on limited budgets and smaller platforms have richer experiences because it not so much about the destination its about the people you meet and often financial status can get in the way of this. But I diverge so will stop here.
Click to expand...

I would love to hear him explain why having money gets in the way of having rich experiences. Guess we're very confused about all the experiences we've had. Guess we should go look for propane and wax a boat to feel fulfilled.

He says it's about the people. Well, more people at marinas than an anchorage as part of the love of anchoring is being away from all the people. And more people while we're exploring the destination on land. We've met thousands of most interesting people including small shop owners, artists and craftsmen. And as to enjoying people, we currently are with a group of 17 friends, about to have dinner at I Sodi in NYC. Does the fact it's an expensive restaurant mean we won't enjoy the company?

I have no issue with those who like simpler or more frugal or those who choose them because of finances. I have no problem with those who are loners or mavericks of various types. The pleasures of boating, as the pleasures of life, aren't limited to any specific ways of doing it. My way isn't better or worse than anyone else's. The thing we all should attempt is to find that way that brings us the most enjoyment, but we don't need to say the experience of others is less rich or less meaningful or less real because it's not our way.
 
Wifey B: And just, for the record, research shows size does matter. :blush:

However, it's just one of many factors. :)
 
BandB said:
Wifey B: And just, for the record, research shows size does matter. :blush:

However, it's just one of many factors. :)
Click to expand...

After working here in Germany for the last 2 weeks and living in hotel rooms as I do so often I am looking forward to getting to my dirt home with a little more size
 
BandB said:
Wifey B: And just, for the record, research shows size does matter. :blush:

However, it's just one of many factors. :)
Click to expand...

We are talking about boats, right?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Back
Top Bottom