mvweebles
Guru
- Joined
- Mar 21, 2019
- Messages
- 9,582
- Location
- United States
- Vessel Name
- Weebles
- Vessel Make
- 1970 Willard 36 Trawler
This thread grew out of a travelogue thread HERE that describes a cruise itinerary of a Willard 36 "Weebles" from California to Florida. The original plan was to do the entire 5000 mile trip on her own bottom but life intervened and there was a pause of 1-year and my wife and I decided to 'catch-up' by shipping Weebles from Golfito on the Pacific Coast of Costa Rica to Florida in January 2025. I broke the Shipping topic out because it comes up from time to time and it just seems like it would benefit from it's own treatment and discussion.
I can only write about my experience. I encourage others with shipping experience to augment this thread, especially for different markets.
Shippers. First, my experience is US West Coast focused. Turns out shippers advertise all sorts of routes but they seem to focus on certain regions. For example (DYT (ex Dockwise float on/off) refers their west coast business to Sevenstar. For me, I was only able to find two shipping companies at time of writing. Sevenstar, and Cross Charters. Cross is more of a broker that seems to charter ships and fills them, slightly different model than a freight-forwarder brokerage.
I had quotes from both Cross ($21.6k) and Sevenstar ($22.5k), both were refreshed around Dec 10th. However......Sevenstar ghosted me shortly thereafter. Paul at Cross tells me they cancelled their ship - he's had a couple last-minute yachts that had been booked on Sevenstar. From Sevenstar's website - note the "To Be Named" on a ship that should be underway (see pic below). Not good. Cross was kind enough to only increase their quote to me by $2k which we negotiated down. Honestly, I thought it was cheesy on their part as their Dec 11th quote was 10-days old and they would not honor it. But we worked it through. Just know it's a shady business in the best of times.
WORD ON COSTS: Best I can tell, shipping costs can be categorized as BC and AC. Before COVID and After COVID. Back when I was noodling over refit of Weebles, I considered shipping her to Florida. Around 2017, I had quotes from Ensenada to Florida for $16k (full disclosure: That was with United Yacht who is no longer in business). Golfito is less than half the distance and is now $22k. Shipping costs skyrocketed during COVID, not just for yacht shipping. Another interesting datapoint is distance between shipping ports is only vaguely reflected in the price. I forget exactly but last I checked was going from Ensenada to Florida isn't much more than Golfito to Florida. I cannot eplain the pretzel logic on this but just know that if you are trying to guesstimate a cost and have a buddy who paid $XXX from Port A to Port B, you're not likely to be close.
Routes. Shippers advertise all sorts of ports-of-call. For example, rather than ship from Golfito, we would have preferred to ship out of Cartegena Colombia or at least Cristobal (Colon) Panama, both of which appear as ports-of-call on either Sevenstar or Cross (or both). But these are not scheduled routes. Best I can tell is there are hefty port fees for a ship to pick-up/drop-off. These are spread across many yachts for scheduled locations. If you want a non-scheduled location, you're in for an eye-watering charge.
Best I can tell, the primary scheduled ports for US West Coast are:
Business Model. When you think through the business model, top of heap are builders (Horizon, PAE, etc) who ship a bunch of boats from Asia to US/EUR markets; then frequent-fliers such as sport-fishing boats and racing boats moving between competitition grounds; then rich folks who move their boats seasonally. Then you have me: once in a lifetime. What that means is CHOOSE WISELY. If you choose on price, you're exposed to risk. Cross seems to have the least-bad reputation in the business.
How the boat is loaded. Pretty straightforward. You come alongside the ship and your hoisted onto the ship (see screen-grab below from Cross). A tender takes you back to the wharf and you're on your own. Offloading is the reverse. Jackstands are welded onto the deck of the ship to fit your boat and it's lashed to the deck.
Not Included. Costs. I asked what other costs should I anticipate. "None - insurance is covered sling-to-sling." Not 2-hours after signing the contract I get an information packet telling me I need a customs agent on both ends. That's reasonable but I wish I had known. Not sure the cost - probably $500 each. Would appreciate input from others. I'll update when I have real information.
The other major cost is plain logistics of getting your boat to the side of the ship and picking it up on the other end. Both days can vary depending on schedule and where your boat will be loaded on deck. You might be first on/off or last. Ship might show-up on the 8th or the 12th. So you will have some costs for either a delivery skipper or accomodations or both.
Boat Prep. Cross provided a decent outline of what to expect. I've attached their PDF (see below). More or less prep as you would for a hurricane. One item of note - lithium batteries need to be declared. I'll update later with how that goes. I'm budgeting a full day to get the boat ready to load.
Shipping vs Delivery on boat's bottom. I'm a bit biased I suppose because I used to deliver boats. Not included in the plus/minus are cost and overall time becuase that varies by boat and circumstance. As mentioned in my "Weebles - Mexico" thread, I made the decision based on time which was largely driven by the prospect of a difficult slog up the Caribbean in a 36-foot boat. Waiting for a weather window could take well over a month. Also not mentioned is cost. For the most part, when it's all said and done, the costs between shipping and delivery are likely close enough that it's not a decisive factor.
The most common reason I heard for people wanting to ship their boat is to preserve engine hours. Most common reason I heard for people wanting their boat delivered is so they can use the boat along the way (go through the Panama Canal, for example). If you have access to a quality, experienced delivery skipper, I'd probably lean towards that. If the skipper is an unknown, I'd take my chances with shipping (boats get dinged in shipping too).
I'll update this thread as I get more information. In the meantime, I hope others who have shipped in the last 5-years (After COVID) will chime in with their experience.
Peter
I can only write about my experience. I encourage others with shipping experience to augment this thread, especially for different markets.
Shippers. First, my experience is US West Coast focused. Turns out shippers advertise all sorts of routes but they seem to focus on certain regions. For example (DYT (ex Dockwise float on/off) refers their west coast business to Sevenstar. For me, I was only able to find two shipping companies at time of writing. Sevenstar, and Cross Charters. Cross is more of a broker that seems to charter ships and fills them, slightly different model than a freight-forwarder brokerage.
I had quotes from both Cross ($21.6k) and Sevenstar ($22.5k), both were refreshed around Dec 10th. However......Sevenstar ghosted me shortly thereafter. Paul at Cross tells me they cancelled their ship - he's had a couple last-minute yachts that had been booked on Sevenstar. From Sevenstar's website - note the "To Be Named" on a ship that should be underway (see pic below). Not good. Cross was kind enough to only increase their quote to me by $2k which we negotiated down. Honestly, I thought it was cheesy on their part as their Dec 11th quote was 10-days old and they would not honor it. But we worked it through. Just know it's a shady business in the best of times.
WORD ON COSTS: Best I can tell, shipping costs can be categorized as BC and AC. Before COVID and After COVID. Back when I was noodling over refit of Weebles, I considered shipping her to Florida. Around 2017, I had quotes from Ensenada to Florida for $16k (full disclosure: That was with United Yacht who is no longer in business). Golfito is less than half the distance and is now $22k. Shipping costs skyrocketed during COVID, not just for yacht shipping. Another interesting datapoint is distance between shipping ports is only vaguely reflected in the price. I forget exactly but last I checked was going from Ensenada to Florida isn't much more than Golfito to Florida. I cannot eplain the pretzel logic on this but just know that if you are trying to guesstimate a cost and have a buddy who paid $XXX from Port A to Port B, you're not likely to be close.
Routes. Shippers advertise all sorts of ports-of-call. For example, rather than ship from Golfito, we would have preferred to ship out of Cartegena Colombia or at least Cristobal (Colon) Panama, both of which appear as ports-of-call on either Sevenstar or Cross (or both). But these are not scheduled routes. Best I can tell is there are hefty port fees for a ship to pick-up/drop-off. These are spread across many yachts for scheduled locations. If you want a non-scheduled location, you're in for an eye-watering charge.
Best I can tell, the primary scheduled ports for US West Coast are:
- Victoria BC
- Ensenada MX
- Golfito CR
- Port Everglades Florida (Ft Lauderdale area).
- Limted regular service to La Paz MX.
- Occassional Service to Houston TX, USVI, Baltimore (Sevenstar)
Business Model. When you think through the business model, top of heap are builders (Horizon, PAE, etc) who ship a bunch of boats from Asia to US/EUR markets; then frequent-fliers such as sport-fishing boats and racing boats moving between competitition grounds; then rich folks who move their boats seasonally. Then you have me: once in a lifetime. What that means is CHOOSE WISELY. If you choose on price, you're exposed to risk. Cross seems to have the least-bad reputation in the business.
How the boat is loaded. Pretty straightforward. You come alongside the ship and your hoisted onto the ship (see screen-grab below from Cross). A tender takes you back to the wharf and you're on your own. Offloading is the reverse. Jackstands are welded onto the deck of the ship to fit your boat and it's lashed to the deck.
Not Included. Costs. I asked what other costs should I anticipate. "None - insurance is covered sling-to-sling." Not 2-hours after signing the contract I get an information packet telling me I need a customs agent on both ends. That's reasonable but I wish I had known. Not sure the cost - probably $500 each. Would appreciate input from others. I'll update when I have real information.
The other major cost is plain logistics of getting your boat to the side of the ship and picking it up on the other end. Both days can vary depending on schedule and where your boat will be loaded on deck. You might be first on/off or last. Ship might show-up on the 8th or the 12th. So you will have some costs for either a delivery skipper or accomodations or both.
Boat Prep. Cross provided a decent outline of what to expect. I've attached their PDF (see below). More or less prep as you would for a hurricane. One item of note - lithium batteries need to be declared. I'll update later with how that goes. I'm budgeting a full day to get the boat ready to load.
Shipping vs Delivery on boat's bottom. I'm a bit biased I suppose because I used to deliver boats. Not included in the plus/minus are cost and overall time becuase that varies by boat and circumstance. As mentioned in my "Weebles - Mexico" thread, I made the decision based on time which was largely driven by the prospect of a difficult slog up the Caribbean in a 36-foot boat. Waiting for a weather window could take well over a month. Also not mentioned is cost. For the most part, when it's all said and done, the costs between shipping and delivery are likely close enough that it's not a decisive factor.
The most common reason I heard for people wanting to ship their boat is to preserve engine hours. Most common reason I heard for people wanting their boat delivered is so they can use the boat along the way (go through the Panama Canal, for example). If you have access to a quality, experienced delivery skipper, I'd probably lean towards that. If the skipper is an unknown, I'd take my chances with shipping (boats get dinged in shipping too).
I'll update this thread as I get more information. In the meantime, I hope others who have shipped in the last 5-years (After COVID) will chime in with their experience.
Peter