ABfish
Senior Member
I pulled the trigger on a bigger dingy, an Achilles HB350DX, and I'm now selecting a crane to go on the foredeck of my boat.
I'm sold on the benefits of a full hydraulic crane (rotation, boom extension, luffing) but I can't find much on drum-type cable winches versus the linear hydraulic winches.
The drum winches are cheaper than the linear winches. Some, such as Nick Jackson, use Warn hoists which means replacement parts are easily obtained. On the other hand, every cable hoist I've ever been around was prone to bird-nesting and usually required some operator's attention when using.
The linear winches are more expensive, but I would assume they are quieter and less prone to cable fouling.
I'm sold on the benefits of a full hydraulic crane (rotation, boom extension, luffing) but I can't find much on drum-type cable winches versus the linear hydraulic winches.
The drum winches are cheaper than the linear winches. Some, such as Nick Jackson, use Warn hoists which means replacement parts are easily obtained. On the other hand, every cable hoist I've ever been around was prone to bird-nesting and usually required some operator's attention when using.
The linear winches are more expensive, but I would assume they are quieter and less prone to cable fouling.