The story of the day (bad but good at the end...)

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

Lou_tribal

Guru
Joined
Jan 20, 2016
Messages
4,375
Location
Canada
Vessel Name
Bleuvet
Vessel Make
Custom Built
Hello TF folks!
This thread is about my story today, bare with me and read it will be interesting!
Today was our departure day for a 3 weeks cruise, that was a 4 weeks cruise at the beginning but went in a 3 weeks cruise because of some health issue in the family... anyway, yesterday we came to the boat, 2 kayak n the car roof, car loaded to the ceiling, 9PM we were on the boat, everything sorted wooo celebration.
Today I started to install my new setup for BBQ (Grill mister RTF :D) everything is looking good, some leaks on the cooktop fitting... ok no drama, disconnected the cooktop will sort that out after our trip, the BBQ (grill) is working fine.
After setup, fresh water tank cleaning, sort everything, tie everything on the deck, we are good to go for refuel, pump out and start the cruise.
4PM, we go to the fuel dock and refuel, 335L all tanks full, connect the pump out... no luck, after 30 minutes the deck hands was not able to get it working, ok no drama (you see I am positive I never see any drama :D ), we will pump out somewhere else on our way...
Now time to start the beast and go cruising, turn the key, engine starts... and I heard a non familiar noise, run to the ER, open the hatch, immediately I saw a liquid cooler hose that was sliding on the alternator belt, urge, took the hose in hand, called my admiral, asked her to grab a tie wrap, tie the hose, ok no drama (again positive lol) just a slight rubber burnt but no real cut everything s fine.
Time to go, slowly go, when some hundreds meters from the dock put in neutral to let my wife grab the fenders, then start at 1200 rpm to warm up... approaching the bridge , increase throttle... then huuuurrrr heard a strange noise, engine is making an unusual noise... not the nice music... Called the wife "Hey look at the exhaust any water coming out?"... answer.... "No"... put in neutral.. run to the ER... open the hatch... half a foot of water in the ER!!! PANNICCC ABOARD WE ARE TAKING WATER IN!!! Run to the dashboard, force all bilge pumps on, the wife was like ""what? what? WHAT?"... asked her to keep a look in the ER if the pumps are running well to keep water level under control, yes, ok one thing in control... Called back the marina PAN PAN PAN taking water need to go back to dock... but the marina was closed nobody there... we headed slowly at the slowest pace possible to the marina (why the slowest? well I thought that if there was no water in the exhaust, and it was not a seacock failure it was certainly a hose that broke apart so lower the rpm, lower the water pumped in ( it was a guess right or wrong).
So after 10 minutes, the wife looking at the ER telling me every minute that water level is fine, we are back to our dock. Tie up, stop the engine, let the ER bilge pump empty the water... OUF we are safe.
Now the diagnostic... After looking at the engine, it revealed it was a hose that popped out on the exhaust manifold... between the heat exchanger and the manifold. Looking at it closely, the stainless collar on the hose was totally loose, not broken, just unscrewed!!!
My conclusions: The f*&^%$# mechanic at the marina unscrewed the collar last winter to winterize the engine (don't ask me why) and did not screw it tight. Why I say so, because first I saw that guy and he did not look to someone who know what he is doing, then because when I left the boat last winter the collar was perfectly tight). After repairing that deadly mistake, I check the engine all over... to discover that have 2 bolt on the exhaust manifold, one at each end, either used to empty the manifold, but I guess they are intended for anodes ( my engine is very rare so it is pure hypothesis here)... one of them as been replaced with a plastic screw that you can remove by hand without even to unscrew it, not even the correct size!!!!
Conclusion: tomorrow the marina owner will receive my sh$%t but I guess he will not care about it... but one thing I am sure... no mechanic here will ever get a foot on my boat.

With all this wasted another day of vacation and cruising. Positive thing I am back and safe, and found the bad sized screw that would have been an issue for sure... but at the end... people working like this, I cannot think good things about them.

L.
 
Greetings,
Mr. L_t. You're safe, the boat is safe. Life is good. No drama.

200.gif
 
I'm sure all days going forward will be better! Good luck.
 
Spring shakedown cruise :)
 
Greetings,
Mr. L_t. You're safe, the boat is safe. Life is good. No drama.

200.gif

Yeah Mr RTF you perfectly understand me, no drama is my motto :D Next step tomorrow... well hopefully there will be a tomorrow :D

Thank you very much!

L.
 
Glad everything turned out good! Now go enjoy!!
 
Glad everything turned out good! Now go enjoy!!

Thank you Donna. In fact it is now fix the issue, check that the clown they hired as mechanic dd not do any other stupid things anywhere then go enjoy :)

L.
 
It's a shame that you have to follow after (so-called) mechanic's to make sure that the work is done properly. Your lucky that you are knowledgeable enough to save your boat and your selves. What might happen to someone who didn't know what to do, or what to look for?
 
All

I think it is prudent for owners to always check whatever the mechanic had done. Anyone can make a mistake,especially ME. Ask those who know me. ��
 
Just think, years from now you'll look back at the start of this cruise and chuckle about it. Or not. But you probably will because there's "no drama".
 
How in the hell can you enjoy a cruise with no drama? Drama makes you enjoy the perfect cruise, one with no problems. NO I have never been on that cruise. :):)
 
Thank you all, you gave me better mind thinking this is not only my case :D

L.
 
We call that a "rocking chair story."
 
We call that a "rocking chair story."

I call this a really bad trip and wasted vacation :)

By the way, found another loose collar on coolant liquid hose today, spent 1h to check all the collar on all hose in the boat.

I duly noted in my book to check these at the start of every season!

L.
 
If you want, I'll offer a discount labor rate to come on your boat and mess things up. But I do charge extra if you want me to do it in the most obscure locations, and the hardest to diagnose.
 
If you want, I'll offer a discount labor rate to come on your boat and mess things up. But I do charge extra if you want me to do it in the most obscure locations, and the hardest to diagnose.

Thank you! We may start a kind of contest like "Find the mess" with a world championship of the best hidden mess at the worst possible place, and time of course :D

L.
 
just think.... you got all the bad karma out of the way so now you're all set.

Fair skies and following seas.

You are totally right, sky has cleared time to put everything else behind and have a ride :) If my issue of shaft seal is not terrible tomorrow we will give it a try, stay tune !
 
Years after our house was built, the roof started to leak. Instead of calling the builder or someone else to fix it, my Dad went up into the attic and followed the leaks meandering path to find out where it came from. What he found was a nail hammered through the shingles from outside.

Someone on the crew had done it when they finished construction on the off chance they'd be back to fix the leak years later.

Dad was not amused!

Not saying that's what happened here, but I'm pretty sure it's happened once or twice before.
 
Last edited:
Today was beautiful in south Florida, overcast yes so we took the boat out to get info for Cummi S. ��
 
Years after our house was built, the roof started to leak. Instead of calling the builder or someone else to fix it, my Dad went up into the attic and followed the leaks meandering path to find out where it came from. What he found was a nail hammered through the shingles from outside.

Someone on the crew had done it when they finished construction on the off chance they'd be back to fix the leak years later.

Dad was not amused!

Not saying that's what happened here, but I'm pretty sure it's happened once or twice before.

I am not kidding when I say I am thinking about the same thing. Look, 2 collars were loose, but when I say loose I do not mean a bit loose but more that I needed more than 10 screw turns to tight them! Is there a way for a collar to loose itself that much??? never saw that. Moreover if this was like that before, the hose that popped out would have popped out last year and not wait now. Then the plug on the exhaust manifold... it was a plastic plug that was not even fitting in place, I removed it just by pulling it by hand, no way this was in place last year during my 150h cruising. I have picture of my engine from all angles taken last year, I will check them for this.

I think I am maybe a bit paranoid but when I see this I am sure about one thing, from now on anytime anybody will get aboard I will be there to check.

L.
 
Then again, whole surgical teams have left sponges inside peoples guts...
 
Then again, whole surgical teams have left sponges inside peoples guts...

Indeed it may not be intentional as it is hard to me to think that it isbut maybe more something like "I removed this I will put it back later" the later never came. As an example, I saw them today checking something on a cruiser, they opened the boat, unlock the door, checked their stuff and they were gone... I guess they thought they will come back later as the boat remained opened... and at the time I type this the boat is still open and nobody is around. I may go to try their bed if it is more comfortable than mine :)

I think there is cruel lack of work management more than anything else, but anyway I will care of my boat myself, at least I will be the only one to blame for any bad luck.

L.
 
Now I call you lucky Lou! Why... cause you made it through. I won't bore you with the facts from yesteryear... but... been there done that [had happen] similar to that.

Be careful. Check every fastening in your boat/engines/through hulls etc that could make sinking a quick possibility.

Now, enjoy your summer!!!!
 
Greetings,
Mr. 42. "...you're spending time messing about on a boat... What's not to like?" I FULLY agree!

Mr. L_t. Hey, you're on vacation and as noted, messing about on your boat. So what if you don't do the loop or get to XX when you planned this shouldn't be a race, I don't think. One plus is that if you need parts or material, you are in an area that you are very familiar with so you don't have to run all around trying to find that ONE thing you need to make repairs. Personally I would much rather find out problems when at my dock than at some remote location.

Another plus may be that since you may not have time to accomplish what you planned is you are now able to spend more time visiting in those places that you would have quickly passed through with your original itinerary. Don't make a loop, go part way and come back the same way...

$.02...
 
Back
Top Bottom