Andre Kunz
Newbie
I am investigating what type (gas, diesel, electric) and what size of dive compressor I should acquire. We are a family of 5 and will only use it to fill the scuba tanks. What is your experience?
Dive compressors
- Thread starter Andre Kunz
- Start date
The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.
O C Diver
Guru
- Joined
- Dec 16, 2010
- Messages
- 12,865
- Location
- USA
- Vessel Name
- Slow Hand
- Vessel Make
- Cherubini Independence 45
I've got lots of experience with scuba tank compressors and given a choice would never want one on my boat. That said, if the only way to get tank fills because of a remote location, is to have your own compressor, so be it. Smaller portable compressors take a long time to fill tanks, have marginal filtration that should be augmented, and have short life expectancies compared to those used in dive stores. When all costs are factored in over the life of the compressor, it will cost you more to fill tanks off your own compressor than carry them to a dive store.
Given a choice, electric is the best choice provided you have a generator big enough to run it. Diesel and gas require you to maintain a motor that may only get occasional use. They also produce toxic gasses (carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide) which must be prevented from entering the compressor intake. For the same capacity electric compressors can often weigh less allowing them to be more easily moved around. Ideally you want to run the compressor outside as they generate a lot of heat. Also operating them at the up wind end of the boat greatly reduces the risk of generator exhaust entering the compressor intake. If this is to be on a large boat with a well ventilated machinery space, the compressor can be mounted below deck provided the air intake is plumbed outside and away from engine and generator exhaust.
If you would like further information, some specifics on your boat and planned use would be helpful.
Ted
Given a choice, electric is the best choice provided you have a generator big enough to run it. Diesel and gas require you to maintain a motor that may only get occasional use. They also produce toxic gasses (carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide) which must be prevented from entering the compressor intake. For the same capacity electric compressors can often weigh less allowing them to be more easily moved around. Ideally you want to run the compressor outside as they generate a lot of heat. Also operating them at the up wind end of the boat greatly reduces the risk of generator exhaust entering the compressor intake. If this is to be on a large boat with a well ventilated machinery space, the compressor can be mounted below deck provided the air intake is plumbed outside and away from engine and generator exhaust.
If you would like further information, some specifics on your boat and planned use would be helpful.
Ted
Andre Kunz
Newbie
Thanks Ted. The scuba shop is not an option as we want to spend a fair bit of time on the water way off the next shop.
Capt.Bill11
Guru
Electric.
Talk to these folks: Brownie's Marine Group - The Worlds Leading Innovator, Designer, Manufacturer and Distributor of Surface Supplied Air Diving Systems and Fully Marinized Compressor Systems
They install compressors on boats all the time.
Talk to these folks: Brownie's Marine Group - The Worlds Leading Innovator, Designer, Manufacturer and Distributor of Surface Supplied Air Diving Systems and Fully Marinized Compressor Systems
They install compressors on boats all the time.
neworleansrich
Senior Member
This year in the Bahamas we have been using a new Max Air 35, powered by a 5hp Honda gas engine. We thought about getting a 220volt unit, but wanted something we could use on other boats.
This is my first summer with a scuba compressor on board. As you may know, there are scuba fill available in Bimini and Nassau, but no longer at Chub or Staniel Cay. If you want to dive off the grid in the Bahamas, get a compressor. A couple of thoughts:
1) We are doing a lot more diving. A lot more
2) We now only carry 4 tanks, rather than the 6 we used to take.
3) Fills in the Bahamas are $10 each, a new filter stack for the Max Air is about $45 and is good for dozens of fills. Gas is minimal. We are already carrying gas for the dinks. Very economical.
4) The Max Air 35 will fill a tank in about 20 min, but you can only fill 2 tanks before you need to let the compressor cool down.
5) The Honda is a bit noisy, but not too bad on the back deck.
The Max Air 35 seems perfect for our needs. It has really added to our cruising enjoyment.
This is my first summer with a scuba compressor on board. As you may know, there are scuba fill available in Bimini and Nassau, but no longer at Chub or Staniel Cay. If you want to dive off the grid in the Bahamas, get a compressor. A couple of thoughts:
1) We are doing a lot more diving. A lot more
2) We now only carry 4 tanks, rather than the 6 we used to take.
3) Fills in the Bahamas are $10 each, a new filter stack for the Max Air is about $45 and is good for dozens of fills. Gas is minimal. We are already carrying gas for the dinks. Very economical.
4) The Max Air 35 will fill a tank in about 20 min, but you can only fill 2 tanks before you need to let the compressor cool down.
5) The Honda is a bit noisy, but not too bad on the back deck.
The Max Air 35 seems perfect for our needs. It has really added to our cruising enjoyment.
Boydski
Senior Member
Hi Andre,
I have a Bauer Capitano on board (~ 8 CFM, electric) that fills tanks in about 15 minutes. I also used to have a RIX oil-less compressor (~ 6 CFM) on one of the dive charter boats and it worked very well (it's designed to run on boats and didn't seem to have corrosion issues like the Bauer does).
They are very convenient when diving in remote locations, especially because I only carry a few tanks rather than a deck full of gear.
The big dive charter boat had a nitrox membrane system on board that filled 14 tanks during a one hour surface interval (hydraulic). It was a lot of work, but each diver usually only brought one tank on board rather than several so it sometimes allowed us to do two trips per day and saved a lot of deck space.
Good Luck,
I have a Bauer Capitano on board (~ 8 CFM, electric) that fills tanks in about 15 minutes. I also used to have a RIX oil-less compressor (~ 6 CFM) on one of the dive charter boats and it worked very well (it's designed to run on boats and didn't seem to have corrosion issues like the Bauer does).
They are very convenient when diving in remote locations, especially because I only carry a few tanks rather than a deck full of gear.
The big dive charter boat had a nitrox membrane system on board that filled 14 tanks during a one hour surface interval (hydraulic). It was a lot of work, but each diver usually only brought one tank on board rather than several so it sometimes allowed us to do two trips per day and saved a lot of deck space.
Good Luck,
Last edited:
