A 240V danger.

The friendliest place on the web for anyone who enjoys boating.
If you have answers, please help by responding to the unanswered posts.

FF

Guru
Joined
Oct 12, 2007
Messages
22,552
Reading on the RV boards there are sad comments of electrical failures from low quality or miss wired 240v plugs.

Seems that if the supply line looses the white neutral all heck breaks loose with electrical devices.

Checking the plugs connections would seem a worthwhile task.

Boat plugs are different , and perhaps made for more abuse , but why not take a look?
 
Last edited:
True, and even homes without main "plugs" have this issue sometimes.
The rest of the world doesn't have this issue of split-phase plus flaky neutral. A boat with a 240V iso transformer also gets rid of the bad plug neutral connection.
 
Have seen a few marine pedestals where the neutral on a 50A 125/250 circuit was toast/loose.... and a lot of expensive TVs, Sat tel, stereos, etc were all fried.
 
On my motorhome I have a Progressive Industries EMS voltage protector. There are a couple other brands. These protect from open neutral, accidental 240v, etc. I've had it prevent problems when the neutral blade on my 50 amp cord broke off and at campgrounds where the pedestal was wired wrong.
Should not be difficult to install one of these in a boat.
 
Have seen a few marine pedestals where the neutral on a 50A 125/250 circuit was toast/loose.... and a lot of expensive TVs, Sat tel, stereos, etc were all fried.

Can someone explain why a neutral in a 50A 124/250 circuit is any different than any other AC connection.

If a neutral is loose then it affects the 120V circuits and they flicker or won't have power. But how is that any different than the hot leg being loose. In other words, what is unique about the neutral?

And how does flickering destroy appliances?

David
 
An open or loose neutral will upset the voltage on both sides of the line. L1 to L2 will be stable at around 240V, but L1 to N and L2 to N will seesaw; worse case is zero volts on one 120 side and 240V on the other side. Application of 240V to most 120V loads will be very bad for them.
 
Reading on the RV boards there are sad comments of electrical failures from low quality or miss wired 240v plugs.

So, if one has high quality plugs and the vessel is wired correctly is there a problem? :confused:
 
So, if one has high quality plugs and the vessel is wired correctly is there a problem? :confused:

only if the dock wiring has issue, or if your flex cable has issue. Or, the connection to the upstream dry transformer has an issue. Beyond those, no issue. :D

HOpefully, you don't have a 3 wire fed 240/120 V clothes dryer on board. :eek:

Mostly, only N. America has this issue where just an OPEN connection can cause a significant shock issue.
 
Last edited:
Reading on the RV boards there are sad comments of electrical failures from low quality or miss wired 240v plugs.

Seems that if the supply line looses the white neutral all heck breaks loose with electrical devices.

Checking the plugs connections would seem a worthwhile task.

Boat plugs are different , and perhaps made for more abuse , but why not take a look?



It’s the thought I had as well. The problem occurs when not connected also. Example: Genset running and not connected to the shore power.
 
Can someone explain why a neutral in a 50A 124/250 circuit is any different than any other AC connection.

If a neutral is loose then it affects the 120V circuits and they flicker or won't have power. But how is that any different than the hot leg being loose. In other words, what is unique about the neutral?

And how does flickering destroy appliances?

David


I hope Diver Dave answered your question.


I am an operator, not an engineer so my brain only goes nto so much detail.


But I have a lot of experience and not reason to BS about what I have seen along the way.


I just lost an inverter/charger to what I think as a loose connection on a 30A power post outlet feeding my smart Y.


It won't charge any more and the auto pass though is intermittent (the whole reason I got rid of 30A shore powerbut am screwed where I am).


Not sure exactly what all the problems are...but the loose connection, possible arcing, rapid off/on, etc...etc...is never good. Have seen it take out electronics in many occasions.
 
So, if one has high quality plugs and the vessel is wired correctly is there a problem? :confused:


In my opinion, old style 30A plugs are an accident waiting to happen.


After 2 weeks away from my boat, a loose end of my 2X30 to 50A smart Y to dock pedestal had one loose side and seems to have cooked my inverter/charger.


For any number of reasons a 30A twist lock can work loose (partially loose). Sure, so can a 50A...but I haven't seen that problem ever....except in CMS posts which I can respect.


But I have seen burnt up 50A connectors which I have no explanation for, but if it's the neutral from being overloaded and cooked, then your 110V appliances aboard can be at risk as Diver Dave points out and I have seen cooked appliances. Whether the issue started with the dock receptacle or boat issues including unbalanced load and overwhelmed neutral...ya got me.
 
Sometimes it is worthy to go into the WHY of a situation, and not just the WHAT.

In N America, unlike most of the rest of the world, we want two different voltages. 240 for "major appliances", and 120V for the rest. This then, is the reason not for a Neutral, but for the two HOT lines on a 240/120V system.
Almost the entire world uses a grounded neutral scheme, but only with a single available voltage. That voltage could be 100, 220, 240V.

The most convenient (cheapest..) way to get two voltages, if they are a factor of 2 different, is to use a center tapped secondary transformer at the utility feed. Voila, now with just 3 wires, I can get two different voltages. In N America, those are 120 and 240. Still have that grounded neutral, and when that particular wire looses its low resistance connection to that center tap, bad things will happen. Not a loss of power, but wildly wrong voltage values. That is the source of the damage, both too high, and too low.

I'll make the bold assumption, that land users started this trend, not boat users. But, you can see that N. American market boats continue the tradition of split phase 120/240 for the larger boats.

Meanwhile, Europe and Asia would have none of this foolishness, and has a simpler, single voltage available for most users. I'm going to exclude industrial users from this discussion, and also 3 phase marine is excluded; since most of the readers here don't use 3 ph for their boat/home service. When a euro 230V boat loses its neutral connection, the voltage simply drops, sometimes all the way to zero. There is no chance for an abnormal high voltage due to neutral loss.

So, that is the madness behind the neutral story.
To the comment I made on the clothes dryer. The rumor is that during/just after WWII, there is a shortage of copper, and it affected home wiring design. Again, to save money, the clothes dryer and usually the electric range wanted both 120 and 240. The safe way to do this is to use 4 wires; L1, L2, N, and safety ground. But no, many installs to this day are still using only 3 wires. L1, L2, and a combined duty N and safety ground. Since this grounded wire carries current (motor and timer), if it becomes disconnected at the source, the frame of the dryer now becomes live with 120V! All other first world countries would not allow such wiring practice. It was about 25 years ago that new installs insist on the 4 wires to any 240/120 appliance.
 
Last edited:
Diver dave, excellent explanation of "why"! I've often puzzled over 3 wire 240 V and wondered how it could be safe?

Another question. Can we use the device folivier uses on his RV on our boats? And if so will it protect those of us still using a single 30 AMP shore power connection should something fail on the marina side of things?

On my motorhome I have a Progressive Industries EMS voltage protector. There are a couple other brands. These protect from open neutral, accidental 240v, etc. I've had it prevent problems when the neutral blade on my 50 amp cord broke off and at campgrounds where the pedestal was wired wrong.
Should not be difficult to install one of these in a boat.
 
DD
No argument with your euro explanation. Having worked around high and low voltage systems internationally I can rudimentally appreciate the differences.

But with my current boating life being spent in Canada and the US I've no choice as to power sources, appliance and dock pedastel wiring. So this being the case, my question remains. If all is visually and electrically OK and none of the hundreds of boats in my marina have not caught fire, what is the issue?
 
Last edited:
If you are wanting to chase "issues", I'd suggest the Boat US insurance leading cause of boat fires.
Now, Is it a problem for YOU? Obviously, this is a game of percentages. Sample sizes of what you mention are small to make an overall judgment of risk, agree?
 
If you are wanting to chase "issues", I'd suggest the Boat US insurance leading cause of boat fires.
Now, Is it a problem for YOU? Obviously, this is a game of percentages. Sample sizes of what you mention are small to make an overall judgment of risk, agree?

DD
While not ignoring the real world tragedies of improperly wired and maintained E systems for NA boats and docks - I'm not grasping your recommendation other than to presumably check and monitor our individual E systems. As FF said in the first post. :confused:
 
Not sure I mentioned any recommendation as yet. But my SAT scores for reading comprehension were low...

However, I will say that on any boat of mine that needs both 240 and 120, I will have a isolation transformer and differential surge suppression. On a 120V boat only, I would reduce that list to only surge protection, both across the line and L to GND.
 
Not sure I mentioned any recommendation as yet. But my SAT scores for reading comprehension were low...

However, I will say that on any boat of mine that needs both 240 and 120, I will have a isolation transformer and differential surge suppression. On a 120V boat only, I would reduce that list to only surge protection, both across the line and L to GND.

Yup, those two items are nice to haves.
 
Is there such thing as a 50A plug tester? One ready-made to plug into a shore power 50A outlet? I know of residential outlet testers, those are handy and compact. I'm not interested in building anything.

I know Hubbel makes ones for 30A connections, but what about 50A?
https://www.hubbell.com/wiringdevic...cking-Device-Accessories/HBLT26CM11/p/2296124

And I may be ignoring the obvious, as marine power connectors and their plug genders are always something I get confused. I can't remember which one uses which.
 
Last edited:
I say no DIY because my point of using one would be two-fold. One to make sure the pedestal I'm about to use isn't defective, and two to have something reasonably authentic looking to show marina personnel why I want a different connection. A frankenstein'd box isn't as likely to accomplish the latter.
 
And here's where I always get a headache... keeping track of which NEMA connector is which...
 
And here's where I always get a headache... keeping track of which NEMA connector is which...

Fortunately there's only a few to remember that are common in marine use:
30A 125V: L5-30
50A 125V: L5-50
50A 125/250V: L14-50
 
A real world story about what can happen when the neutral is not connected on a 240V circuit...

We had a tree fall on our power line coming to the house. The power company failed to connect the neutral but told me that we were back up and to turn on my breaker to see if everything was OK.

Light bulbs popped, lots of electronics were fried, even some surge suppressors smoked. With a floating neutral and an uneven load on the two lines, we had 80V on one line and 150V on the other. A very expensive mistake!
 
Ouch. Thats like testing a seat belt by driving into a tree. POCO should have known better.
 
A real world story about what can happen when the neutral is not connected on a 240V circuit...

We had a tree fall on our power line coming to the house. The power company failed to connect the neutral but told me that we were back up and to turn on my breaker to see if everything was OK.

Light bulbs popped, lots of electronics were fried, even some surge suppressors smoked. With a floating neutral and an uneven load on the two lines, we had 80V on one line and 150V on the other. A very expensive mistake!

Ha! Same thing happened here. Lost all sorts of appliances. Power company just wrote us a check.
 
Here is a DIY 50 amp tester:
50-amp Tester

You'd need to use the appropriate cable ends.

If I were using it at a marina I'd want to have something as 'ready made' looking as possible. Not a DIY hack. The point being if there's something wrong having something that doesn't look like a contraption is, perhaps, more likely to get them to believe it.

Think of it this way, you have someone come up to your dock and plug in some Frankenstein of a device that tells them something is wrong with your plug. Are you going to believe them? Now, if it was the more typical plug-looking device I'd think that would make a better impression and lead to more cooperation.

Still, for personal use, yeah, even a bodged together gizmo is better than blown electrical gear on board.
 
The majority of the "DIY gizmo" is off the shelf stuff, shouldn't be hard for a marina guy with about 10 seconds worth of electrical knowledge to see the troubleshooting devices are store bought and just plugged into a simple receptacle.


I my experience, it would work fine as most of the time you report an electrical problem at a marina, they take it pretty seriously no matter if you can articulate the exact problem or you say "my boat doesn't work when I plug it in".
 
Back
Top Bottom