Wxx3
Dauntless Award
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2013
- Messages
- 2,820
- Location
- USA
- Vessel Name
- Dauntless
- Vessel Make
- Kadey Krogen 42 - 148
I think it's great that there are courses to help understand weather better.
I take exception to the phraseology of this ad. I wrote Passage Maker about it last month, but they seemed not to understand my concern.
"Chris Parker has been the cruiser’s best friend since the dawn of the millennium, when he began giving weather routing advice. Heading from Newport to Bermuda? Crossing the Gulf Stream? Hiking the “Thorny Path” to the Caribbean? Parker has always been there for us. Now he’s sharing his wisdom with a pair of online courses, beginning with Weather 101, Basics, a Boaters University course which lays the foundation for Weather 202, Advanced (coming soon). Together they teach forecasting essentials, enabling us to evaluate commercial and government weather predictions and make independent decisions."
It's these last four words: “and make independent decisions” is what I take exception to.
One, two or three+ weather courses cannot make you a weather forecaster. They can help you understand how numerical weather forecasts are made, but to say or even imply that you will be able to pick one model over another (making independent decisions) for any given space and time is fallacious at best, and possibly dangerous at worse.
I don’t want to get into a lawyer’s argument about what “independent” means. As skippers of our boats, we all make independent decisions all the time.
But taking courses by Chris Parker, will not make you forecast like Chris Parker.
https://view.e.aimmedia.com/?qs=7422b91f76750f65b79e857030b3b875cf8fb4d07acf545156d015901a59e64da437955f351c2bcea33cfc0c0c0f7d87a7c72bdbe05aa616b4d78f706d33f7ee2aed7e411000f872a46c61cca715f290
I take exception to the phraseology of this ad. I wrote Passage Maker about it last month, but they seemed not to understand my concern.
"Chris Parker has been the cruiser’s best friend since the dawn of the millennium, when he began giving weather routing advice. Heading from Newport to Bermuda? Crossing the Gulf Stream? Hiking the “Thorny Path” to the Caribbean? Parker has always been there for us. Now he’s sharing his wisdom with a pair of online courses, beginning with Weather 101, Basics, a Boaters University course which lays the foundation for Weather 202, Advanced (coming soon). Together they teach forecasting essentials, enabling us to evaluate commercial and government weather predictions and make independent decisions."
It's these last four words: “and make independent decisions” is what I take exception to.
One, two or three+ weather courses cannot make you a weather forecaster. They can help you understand how numerical weather forecasts are made, but to say or even imply that you will be able to pick one model over another (making independent decisions) for any given space and time is fallacious at best, and possibly dangerous at worse.
I don’t want to get into a lawyer’s argument about what “independent” means. As skippers of our boats, we all make independent decisions all the time.
But taking courses by Chris Parker, will not make you forecast like Chris Parker.
https://view.e.aimmedia.com/?qs=7422b91f76750f65b79e857030b3b875cf8fb4d07acf545156d015901a59e64da437955f351c2bcea33cfc0c0c0f7d87a7c72bdbe05aa616b4d78f706d33f7ee2aed7e411000f872a46c61cca715f290
Last edited: